More and more clients have come to me lately to tell me that the Board will approve the sale if the contact price is greater than what the buyer agreed to pay. This article from BrickUnderground speaks to some of the possible options when faced with this issue.
Are buyers and sellers exaggerating sales prices at the behest of price-sensitive co-op boards?
In the post-Lehman market, roughly 1 in 10 co-op sales are recorded at misleadingly high prices to appease boards defending their property values, according to several lawyers and a mortgage broker who spoke to BrickUnderground.
Here’s how it works:
Though not unheard of prior to the current real estate downturn, the pace has picked up considerably since.
“If handled correctly,” says real estate lawyer Jeffrey Reich, “credits and allowances provide a win-win alternative for the seller, purchaser, board and shareholders, whose apartment values are protected.”
The practice is legal so long as both the co-op board and the lender know about the agreement to refund money.
However, explains Manhattan real estate lawyer Jerry Feeney, “banks don’t like it because it’s not really reflecting the true economic value of the transaction. If it exceeds 6 percent of the purchase price, they will reject it, and they are often reducing valuations on the property according to the amount of the seller’s concession.”
To get around lender restrictions on allowances and credits, Feeney said he had begun to create “renovation escrows” instead in situations where a buyer intends to renovate.
“Banks look at it as a seller’s obligation to make repairs secured by an escrow rather than a credit that goes back into the buyer’s pocket,” he says.
Richard Martin, senior vice president of DE Capital Mortgage, said the escrow approach was relatively new.
“It’s a pretty smart way around,” he said, agreeing with Feeney that lenders would not restrict the renovation escrows. “It’s guaranteeing that the money will be reinvested in the property and maintain the value.”
While credits, allowances and renovation escrows may be legal, they are not precisely victimless.
“Who loses?” says Reich. “Potentially future purchases and lenders, who will receive inaccurate pricing information when searching for comparables.”
In other words, without knowing the underlying terms of a sale, the next of buyer (and mortgage lender) of that apartment or any other in the building will believe that the apartment is more valuable than it actually is.
(In addition to asking about bed bugs and assessments during due diligence, buyers might want to start asking managing agents whether they are aware of any prior givebacks in the building)
Seller concessions are far more widespread in new construction.
Since 2007, developers have aggressively given concessions like closing costs, six months common charges, health club membership, decorating allowances, mortgage points, etc., explains real estate market analyst and appraiserJonathan Miller.
As a result, says Feeney, “sales prices are wildly overstated in new construction. You can’t tell just from the reported price what it really sold for.”
Are givebacks creating a rosier-than-warranted picture of New York City property values overall?
Miller says that a 1-in-10 rate of givebacks probably doesn’t alter the picture in a significant way for resales. But the opposite is true for new construction.
“It does skew that market,” says Miller.
"My name is Emilio. When I was buying my property, I hired Mr William J Reinhardt Jr as my Real Estate Attorney, it was one of the best decision I ever made because he did everything in his power to make sure my purchase was successful. For example, The utilities bills left over by the person who owned the property before me. I said thank you to Bill for not allow me to pay these costly bills." - 5.0 stars | Posted by Emilio Bien Aime | October 1, 2019
"Mr. William Reinhardt Jr. is my lawyer for many years. My family and I bought and sold properties with his help and were very satisfied. I recommend Mr. Reinhardt to anyone. I give him a 5-star review." - 5.0 stars | Posted by Diana | September 19, 2019
"My husband and I loved working with William. He was very professional, efficient and went above and beyond to help us. We would HIGHLY recommend." - 5.0 stars | Posted by Leeann | September 13, 2019